The world of mystery board games is a fascinating one, filled with intrigue, deception, and intellectual challenge. For those who enjoy solving puzzles and unraveling mysteries, these games offer a unique and engaging experience. In this article, we will explore five mystery board games that are sure to test your detective skills and keep you on the edge of your seat.
Key Points
- Clue: A classic detective game where players must solve the mystery of who killed the victim.
- Mysterium: A cooperative game where one player takes on the role of a ghost trying to communicate with the other players to solve a murder mystery.
- Deception: A social deduction game where one player takes on the role of a spy trying to deceive the other players.
- Sherlock Holmes: A cooperative game where players take on the roles of Sherlock Holmes and his trusted sidekick, Dr. Watson, to solve a series of mysteries.
- Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert: A cooperative game where players work together to retrieve four treasures from an island/desert before it sinks/gets buried in sand.
Game Overview: Clue

Clue is a classic detective game that has been a staple of board game collections for decades. In this game, players take on the roles of detectives trying to solve the mystery of who killed the victim. The game is set in a mansion, where the players must gather clues and piece together the events of the night to uncover the identity of the killer. With its simple yet engaging gameplay, Clue is a great introduction to the world of mystery board games.
Gameplay Mechanics: Clue
The gameplay mechanics of Clue are straightforward. Each player chooses a character and rolls the dice to determine how many spaces they can move on their turn. The players then draw clue cards, which provide information about the suspect, the location, and the weapon used in the crime. The players must use this information to deduce who the killer is and where the crime took place. The game ends when one player correctly accuses the killer, or when all the players have made an accusation and the killer is revealed.
Game Overview: Mysterium

Mysterium is a cooperative game where one player takes on the role of a ghost trying to communicate with the other players to solve a murder mystery. The ghost player must use a variety of clues, including visions and intuitions, to guide the other players towards the solution. The game is set in a haunted mansion, where the players must work together to uncover the truth behind the murder. With its unique gameplay mechanics and cooperative gameplay, Mysterium is a great choice for those who enjoy working together to solve a mystery.
Gameplay Mechanics: Mysterium
The gameplay mechanics of Mysterium are complex and engaging. The ghost player must use a variety of clues to guide the other players towards the solution. The players must then use these clues to deduce the identity of the killer, the location of the crime, and the object used in the crime. The game ends when the players have correctly solved the mystery, or when the ghost player has run out of time and the mystery remains unsolved.
Game Overview: Deception
Deception is a social deduction game where one player takes on the role of a spy trying to deceive the other players. The spy player must use a variety of tactics, including lies and misdirection, to convince the other players that they are not the spy. The game is set in a world of espionage, where the players must use their skills of deduction to uncover the identity of the spy. With its social gameplay and deductive mechanics, Deception is a great choice for those who enjoy games of deception and strategy.
Gameplay Mechanics: Deception
The gameplay mechanics of Deception are simple yet engaging. The spy player must use a variety of tactics to deceive the other players, while the other players must use their skills of deduction to uncover the identity of the spy. The game ends when the players have correctly identified the spy, or when the spy has successfully deceived the other players and remains undetected.
Game Overview: Sherlock Holmes
Sherlock Holmes is a cooperative game where players take on the roles of Sherlock Holmes and his trusted sidekick, Dr. Watson, to solve a series of mysteries. The game is set in the world of Sherlock Holmes, where the players must use their skills of deduction to solve a variety of cases. With its cooperative gameplay and deductive mechanics, Sherlock Holmes is a great choice for those who enjoy working together to solve a mystery.
Gameplay Mechanics: Sherlock Holmes
The gameplay mechanics of Sherlock Holmes are complex and engaging. The players must use a variety of clues and deductions to solve the cases, while also managing their resources and time. The game ends when the players have solved all the cases, or when they have run out of time and the cases remain unsolved.
Game Overview: Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert

Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert is a cooperative game where players work together to retrieve four treasures from an island/desert before it sinks/gets buried in sand. The game is set in a world of adventure, where the players must use their skills of strategy and cooperation to succeed. With its cooperative gameplay and time-sensitive mechanics, Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert is a great choice for those who enjoy working together to achieve a common goal.
Gameplay Mechanics: Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert
The gameplay mechanics of Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert are simple yet engaging. The players must work together to retrieve the treasures, while also managing the island/desert and the resources. The game ends when the players have retrieved all the treasures, or when the island/desert has sunk/been buried in sand and the treasures are lost.
| Game | Number of Players | Playtime |
|---|---|---|
| Clue | 3-6 | 30-60 minutes |
| Mysterium | 2-7 | 30-60 minutes |
| Deception | 4-12 | 20-40 minutes |
| Sherlock Holmes | 1-2 | 60-90 minutes |
| Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert | 2-4 | 20-30 minutes |

What is the most challenging mystery board game?
+The most challenging mystery board game is often subjective and depends on the player's experience and skill level. However, Mysterium is often considered one of the most challenging mystery board games due to its complex gameplay mechanics and cooperative gameplay.
What is the best mystery board game for beginners?
+The best mystery board game for beginners is often Clue, due to its simple gameplay mechanics and intuitive rules. Clue is a great introduction to the world of mystery board games and is easy to learn and play.
Can mystery board games be played solo?
+Yes, some mystery board games can be played solo. For example, Sherlock Holmes is a cooperative game that can be played solo, where the player takes on the role of Sherlock Holmes and must solve the cases on their own.
In conclusion, mystery board games offer a unique and engaging experience for those who enjoy solving puzzles and unraveling mysteries. From classic games like Clue to more complex games like Mysterium, there is a mystery board game out there for everyone. Whether you’re playing solo or with a group, mystery board games are a great way to challenge your detective skills and have fun at the same time.